Top 10 Myths About Fine Rugs

There’s a particular kind of confidence that comes with owning a fine rug. You walk into a room, admire the hand-knotted silk medallion beneath your coffee table, and feel like you finally have your life together.

Then someone at a dinner party says something completely wrong about it, and you nod politely because, honestly, you’re not entirely sure they’re wrong. Let me fix that.

After years of reporting on design, craftsmanship, and the occasionally baffling world of textile arts, I’ve collected the most stubborn myths about fine rugs and I’m here to unravel them, one thread at a time.

Myth #1: Fine Rugs Are Only for People with Fancy Last Names

The belief that fine rugs are exclusively the domain of old-money families with hyphenated surnames is, frankly, outdated. The rug market today is remarkably democratic.

Yes, a museum-quality Persian Tabriz from the 19th century might set you back six figures, but exceptional hand-knotted rugs from regions like India, Morocco, and Turkey can be found for a few hundred to a few thousand dollars.

Quality craftsmanship is more accessible than the velvet-rope mythology around it suggests.

Myth #2: Machine-Made Rugs Are Just as Good

I’ve heard this one more times than I care to count, usually said defensively by someone standing on a machine-made rug. Here’s the truth: a hand-knotted rug is not simply a floor covering.

It is a record of human labor, sometimes representing years of work by multiple artisans. The knot density, the variation in pile height, the organic irregularities in pattern, these are not flaws. They are the fingerprints of the maker.

A machine-made rug can approximate the look, but it cannot replicate the soul, or, for that matter, the durability. Hand-knotted rugs routinely outlast the houses they’re placed in.

Myth #3: You Should Never Put Furniture on a Fine Rug

This myth has caused more awkward living room arrangements than I care to imagine, with sofas hovering at the edges of beautiful rugs like nervous party guests afraid to come inside.

The reality is that placing furniture on a fine rug is not only acceptable, it’s often recommended. Furniture legs help anchor the rug, reduce movement, and actually protect high-traffic areas.

The only caveat worth mentioning: use furniture coasters or felt pads to distribute weight and avoid crushing the pile permanently in one spot.

Myth #4: Silk Rugs Are the Most Durable

Silk rugs are, without question, among the most visually stunning objects humans have ever produced. The way light moves across a silk pile can make a grown interior designer weep with joy. But durable? Not particularly.

Silk is a delicate fiber, vulnerable to moisture, heavy foot traffic, and the general chaos of daily life. A silk rug belongs in a low-traffic space where it can be admired rather than tramped across by people who haven’t removed their shoes.

For high-traffic areas, a well-made wool rug will outperform silk every time.

Myth #5: Older Always Means More Valuable

Age is not a synonym for value in the rug world, much like it isn’t in other areas of life I’d rather not dwell on. An antique rug that has been poorly stored, improperly cleaned, or repaired with mismatched wool can be worth far less than a well-executed contemporary piece from a master weaver.

What collectors and appraisers actually look at is a combination of provenance, condition, knot count, dye quality, and regional rarity. A rug that’s been sitting in a damp basement for fifty years has not aged like fine wine.

Myth #6: You Can Clean a Fine Rug with a Regular Vacuum

This is where I have to be direct: please stop aggressively vacuuming your hand-knotted rugs with a beater brush attachment. The rotating brush that works wonderfully on wall-to-wall carpeting can fray the pile and fringe of a fine rug over time.

The correct approach is to vacuum on a low suction setting, moving in the direction of the pile, and to avoid the fringe entirely. For a proper deep clean, a professional rug washing service, one that hand-washes and dries flat, is the only real option. It costs less than a repair bill.

Myth #7: The Price Tag Tells You Everything

Retail markup in the rug industry can be, to put it charitably, theatrical. A rug priced at ten thousand dollars in a showroom is not necessarily twice the rug that costs five thousand dollars at an estate sale.

Provenance, purchase context, and the seller’s overhead all play enormous roles in pricing. Learning to evaluate rugs by their construction, material, and condition rather than their sticker price is the skill that separates informed buyers from people who walk out feeling vaguely robbed.

Myth #8: Bold Rugs Are Hard to Decorate Around

Every few years, some corner of the design world decides that neutral rugs are the sophisticated choice and that anything with a bold pattern is somehow unsophisticated.

This is incorrect and also a little boring. A commanding geometric Moroccan rug or a richly colored Heriz can anchor a room and give it a personality that no greige rectangle ever will.

The trick is not to avoid pattern but to pull one or two colors from the rug and echo them elsewhere in the room. Bold rugs are not decorating problems. They are decorating solutions.

Myth #9: All Oriental Rugs Come from the Orient

The term “Oriental rug” is one of the most misused phrases in the design world. Technically, it refers to rugs hand-knotted in a broad swath of the world stretching from North Africa through the Middle East and Central Asia to China and India. It is not a style. It is a geography.

A Moroccan Beni Ourain and a Chinese Peking rug are both technically Oriental rugs despite looking nothing alike. Meanwhile, plenty of rugs sold as “Oriental-style” are made in Romania or Belgium on power looms. Read the label. Ask questions.

Myth #10: Fine Rugs Are an Expense, Not an Investment

This is the myth I find most worth correcting, because it changes how people think about buying rugs entirely. While I’ll stop short of telling anyone to liquidate their 401(k) for a Qum silk prayer rug, the historical record is clear: exceptional rugs from renowned weaving regions have appreciated significantly over time.

A 19th-century Feraghan Sarouk purchased in the 1970s for a few thousand dollars might fetch twenty times that today at a major auction house. Even setting aside appreciation, a well-chosen rug purchased for quality rather than trend will outlast virtually every other decorating decision you make and look better for it.

Bottom Line

The next time someone at a dinner party starts confidently stating nonsense about fine rugs, you’ll be ready. And if it turns out that the nonsense is coming from you, well, now you know better.

Rugs reward the curious, the patient, and the willing to get down on their knees and actually look at the knots. Start there.

If you buy something on this page, we may get a small share of sale at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products that we have used ourselves and feel are really useful, not because of the limited compensation from the links through our posts.